top of page

Skull and Bones Alternatives: Find Your Perfect Pirate Game

After years of anticipation, Skull and Bones has finally arrived, yet its reception has been decidedly mixed. While the core naval combat offers thrills, many players and critics find the overall experience hampered by repetitive gameplay and a lackluster story. If you're a hesitant pirate seeking a more fulfilling experience on the high seas, fear not -- there are plenty of excellent alternatives waiting to be discovered.

Ships track and attack each other on the open seas in Skull and Bones. A large ship in the foreground is sailing away from a larger pirate ship in the background.
Set Sail With Skull and Bones

Top 8 Games Like Skull and Bones

In this article, we'll explore various games that offer similar themes and mechanics to Skull and Bones, each with its own unique twist. From open-world adventures to intense ship combat, these titles provide a range of experiences for fans of the pirate genre. Whether you're looking for a more immersive world, a different visual style, or a more diverse experience, you'll find plenty of options to consider. Be sure to check out our YouTube video below for a closer look at each game and how they compare to Skull and Bones.

1. Sea of Thieves (Xbox, PC, 2018)

Rare's beloved pirate sandbox puts the emphasis on shared adventures and player-driven antics. Sea of Thieves' world is vibrant and whimsical, filled with hidden treasure, fearsome skeleton crews, and the potential for hilarious (or treacherous) encounters with other players.

Key Similarities to Skull and Bones: Open-world exploration, ship-to-ship combat, treasure hunts, and dynamic encounters driven by player interaction.

What I Like: The emergent gameplay is where Sea of Thieves shines. You never know what the next island might hold or what other crews might cross your path. The intuitive sailing mechanics and constant content updates keep the experience fresh.

What I Don't Like: The progression can sometimes feel a bit grindy, and hand-to-hand combat isn't the most refined aspect.

The "X" Factor: If you dream of a true pirate fantasy where you create your own hilarious and thrilling stories with a crew of friends, this is your game.

Game Type: Multiplayer, Live Service

A group of pirates gather and dance in Sea of Thieves
Get The Party Started In Sea of Thieves

2. Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag (Multiplatform, 2013)

Black Flag is widely regarded as one of the best pirate experiences out there. Step into the shoes of Edward Kenway as he navigates the treacherous waters of the Caribbean, engages in thrilling naval battles, and uncovers a shadowy conspiracy within the Assassin's Creed universe.

Key Similarities to Skull and Bones: Open-world setting, thrilling naval combat, and in-depth ship customization.

What I Like: Black Flag balances intense pirate action with a well-crafted, overarching narrative. Upgrading your ship, the Jackdaw, is incredibly satisfying and seamlessly integrated into the adventure.

What I Don't Like: The on-foot Assassin missions sometimes feel less compelling than the naval action, and the present-day storyline can pull you out of the historical setting.

The "X" Factor: Black Flag offers a fantastic pirate adventure intertwined with a compelling story for those who enjoy a more structured experience.

Game Type: Single-Player, Campaign

Blackbeard the pirate laughs in Assassin's Creed 4 Black Flag
A Tall Tale Awaits In Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag

3. Blackwake (PC, 2017)

A unique, entirely multiplayer naval warfare experience. Blackwake demands teamwork and coordination as you and your crew sail, fire cannons, and desperately repair your ship in the heat of chaotic battles.

Key Similarities to Skull and Bones: Focus on ship-to-ship combat with customizable ship options.

What I Like: The thrill of working together as a well-oiled crew to survive intense encounters is unmatched. Blackwake offers a level of tactical complexity that sets it apart from other pirate titles.

What I Don't Like: The steep learning curve can be daunting, and without a dedicated group, the experience can turn chaotic.

The "X" Factor: If you seek the most intense, realistic, and teamwork-oriented naval combat experience out there, Blackwake is your answer.

Game Type: Multiplayer

A ship crew member lights a cannon as it aims at the enemy ship in the game Blackwake
Battle With Pride In Blackwake

4. World of Warships (PC, 2015)

Wargaming's tactical naval combat game puts a significant focus on historical accuracy. Players command a vast selection of warships from the early 20th century, engaging in meticulously calculated battles with an emphasis on strategy and positioning.

Key Similarities to Skull and Bones: A shared love of naval warfare, though the approach in World of Warships is decidedly more methodical and realistic.

What I Like: The historical accuracy and detailed ship models are impressive. If you're a naval buff, the focus on strategy and the wide array of ship classes will be deeply satisfying.

What I Don't Like: The slower pace and emphasis on technical aspects might not be for everyone seeking a swashbuckling pirate adventure.

The "X" Factor: World of Warships is perfect for players who want a more serious and historically grounded take on naval combat.

Game Type: Multiplayer, Free-to-Play

Two battleships exchange missle fire on the open seas in the game World of Warships
Strategy Is Key In World of Warships

5. Naval Action (PC, 2019)

A niche title aimed squarely at hardcore enthusiasts. Naval Action is set during the Age of Sail and boasts a deep, almost intimidating, level of realism in its sailing and combat mechanics.

Key Similarities to Skull and Bones: Ship customization and the open-world setting provide a basic parallel. However, Naval Action is on a whole other level of complexity.

What I Like: The meticulous simulation of everything from wind direction to sail damage creates an incredibly immersive experience for those who appreciate absolute realism.

What I Don't Like: The learning curve is incredibly steep, and the gameplay can feel downright inaccessible to more casual players.

The "X" Factor: Naval Action offers a truly unique experience for those who want to feel like they've stepped onto a historically accurate ship of the line. This is not for the faint of heart.

Game Type: Multiplayer

An American ship from the 18th century sails the open seas in the game Naval Action
Authentic Boat Battles In Naval Action

6. King of Seas (PC, Consoles, 2021)

A top-down action RPG with a vibrant, almost cartoony aesthetic. King of Seas offers ship customization, a fantastical story, and arcade-style naval combat with various ship abilities.

Key Similarities to Skull and Bones: Ship upgrades, a dynamic reputation system, and a focus on naval combat.

What I Like: King of Seas provides a more casual and lighthearted take on the pirate theme. The combat is fast-paced and engaging, and the story has a fun, whimsical tone.

What I Don't Like: The top-down perspective might not be for everyone, and the depth of the game is not as significant as in some other titles.

The "X" Factor: If you're looking for a pirate adventure that's easy to pick up and offers a good mix of exploration, combat, and humor, King of Seas is worth checking out.

Game Type: Single-Player, RPG

A skull on the front of a shost ship, with two ships on the sides, sailing through open waters in King Of Seas.
A Top-Down Arcade Adventure In King Of Seas

7. Tempest (PC, Mobile, 2016)

An open-world pirate RPG with a heavy focus on ship combat. Tempest lets you explore the seas, trade goods, and engage in ship-to-ship battles, all while upgrading your vessel and hiring a capable crew.

Key Similarities to Skull and Bones: The emphasis on ship combat and customization, as well as the open-world exploration.

What I Like: Tempest is a solid blend of RPG elements and action-packed naval combat. The ability to customize your ship and crew adds a nice layer of strategy to the game.

What I Don't Like: The graphics and overall polish might not be up to par with some of the bigger titles on this list, and the mobile roots are sometimes apparent in the UI.

The "X" Factor: For those seeking a more traditional RPG experience with a strong focus on piracy and naval combat, Tempest is a solid choice.

Game Type: Single-Player, RPG

A large pirate ship sails near lava in the game Tempest
Mega Boat Battle Action In Tempest

8. Atlas (PC, Xbox, 2018)

An ambitious MMO that blends elements of survival, exploration, and naval combat. In Atlas, players can build their own ships, form alliances, conquer territories, and navigate a massive open world filled with danger and opportunity.

Key Similarities to Skull and Bones: Open-world exploration, ship customization, and a focus on naval combat and piracy.

What I Like: Atlas offers a vast, dynamic world where players can truly carve out their own destiny. The scale of the game is impressive, with the ability to build massive fleets and engage in large-scale battles.

What I Don't Like: The game can be overwhelming for new players, and it has faced criticism for performance issues and a steep learning curve. It's also been in "early access" for the past six years, making me wonder if there's ever going to be a final "polished" version.

The "X" Factor: If you're looking for a game where you can lose yourself in a sprawling world of piracy and adventure, with the freedom to build your own empire on the high seas, Atlas might be the game for you.

Game Type: Multiplayer, MMO

Soliders battle a four0headed dragon and another large monster in the game Atlas
An Epic Pirate World Lives In Atlas

McScratchey's Final Thoughts

While Skull and Bones might have left some players wanting more, the world of pirate-themed games is vast and varied. Whether you're looking for a light-hearted adventure, a deep simulation, or intense multiplayer action, there's a game out there for every type of pirate enthusiast. So, hoist your sails, plot your course, and set sail for your perfect pirate adventure!


bottom of page